Category Archives: commentary

Insights on Magisterial Authority

There are three types of infallibility of the Magisterium: A. Papal Infallibility – solemn definitions of the Pope B. Conciliar Infallibility – solemn definition of the body of Bishops gathered with the Pope at an Ecumenical Council C. Ordinary and … Continue reading

Gallery | Leave a comment

The Search for Loopholes in the Magisterium

The Vatican II loophole: the claim that since Vatican II, everything has changed, and therefore the older Councils and teachings can be ignored or revised. This is a common liberal claim, and it is contrary to faith. Whether you consider … Continue reading

Gallery | 2 Comments

A Second Wave of Covid-19 Cases This Winter

A second wave of Covid-19 cases and deaths is coming to the U.S. and other nations this winter. July had 2 million cases and 26,000 deaths. The winter months could have anywhere from 5 to 10 to 15 million cases … Continue reading

Gallery | Leave a comment

When the Church was right about Science

Since at least Vatican I, the Catholic Church has taught that the universe (material Creation) was created at a certain point in time (essentially at the beginning of Time) and that it is finite. But as late as the 1920’s, … Continue reading

Gallery | 2 Comments

Cardinal Manning on Vatican I

The Vatican Council and Its Definitions: A Pastoral Letter to the Clergy by Henry Edward Manning, Archbishop of Westminster, one of the fathers of the First Vatican Council. The above link is to a digitized and OCRed copy of the … Continue reading

Gallery | Leave a comment

A Condemnation of the Book Christus Vincit

The book in question is titled “Christus Vincit”, meaning “Christ Conquers” [1]. What kind of a book it is? It’s an interview book; Bishop Athanasius Schneider is interviewed by Diane Montagna. Be advised that I have nothing against Ms. Montagna, … Continue reading

Gallery | 11 Comments

The Infallibility of Ecumenical Councils

Formerly, I thought that Councils could teach infallibly, or non-infallibly. And the non-infallible teachings had limited possibility of error. But Bellarmine says that everything taught by a Council (i.e. on faith and morals) is infallible, as the teaching is of … Continue reading

Gallery | 2 Comments

Reply to Peter Kwasniewski’s Three Possibilities on Vatican II

Over at OnePeterFive, Peter wrote an article titled: “Why Viganò’s Critique of the Council Must Be Taken Seriously”. Is the answer, because there’s an internet? Vigano would not have fared well under any Pope before the internet, as he would … Continue reading

Gallery | 5 Comments

Faith in the True Magisterium

Each and every valid Roman Pontiff, from Peter to Francis and beyond has the divinely-conferred charism of truth and never failing faith. A Pope is necessarily the valid Roman Pontiff who is accepted by the body of Bishops as the … Continue reading

Gallery | 2 Comments

Fr. Chad Ripperger accuses Saint Peter

In making accusation after accusation against Pope after Pope, Ripperger accuses Saint Peter of the same. For nothing is permitted to the successors of Peter that was not permitted of Peter himself. And finally, Ripperger does accuse Peter himself. I … Continue reading

Gallery | 6 Comments

Can a Pope teach grave error or heresy inadvertently or inculpably?

Can a Pope teach an objective heresy or other grave error, inculpably, by ignorance, and without any deliberate knowing fault? In such a case, he would not be guilty of formal heresy, but his teaching would be either material heresy, … Continue reading

Gallery | 2 Comments

Bellarmine, Taylor Marshall, and Ryan Grant on Papal Faith

First, a review of what Bellarmine says. In the book On the Roman Pontiff, book 2, chapter 30, Saint Robert Bellarmine considers a proposition called “the tenth argument”. “The tenth argument. A Pope can be judged and deposed by the … Continue reading

Gallery | 2 Comments

Do the papal accusers have any faith at all?

I honestly wonder whether some of the papal accusers might possibly be devoid of supernatural faith. I can’t know if that is the case or not by their exterior and very public sins. But I have to wonder. They don’t … Continue reading

Gallery | 1 Comment

Fertile Soil for the Seeds of Schism

*conservative Catholics are being put to the test by God* Heresy is fertile soil for the seeds of schism. Before the reign of Pope Francis, during the papacies of Pope Saint John Paul II and Pope Benedict XVI, I noticed … Continue reading

Gallery | Leave a comment

My article on Hydroxychloroquine

Is hydroxychloroquine effective against Covid-19? See my article on And don’t call it the “Trump drug”. Medical care and science should not be politicized. RLCJ

Gallery | Leave a comment

Is Taylor Marshall a sedevacantist? Yes.

I would say, “Yes.” His book “Infiltration” accuses every Pope from Pius 12th to Pope Francis of grave errors on doctrine and discipline, and accuses Vatican II of teaching heresy. A heretical Pope cannot be valid. So, having accused the … Continue reading

Gallery | 6 Comments

How can I obtain the help of God?

Do you have a serious problem that requires the help of God? Prayer, self-denial, and works of mercy are the path to salvation and the path to obtaining the grace and providence of God. But if you have a particularly … Continue reading

Gallery | Leave a comment

Proof that Communion on the Tongue does not Preserve Orthodoxy

So the claim is made that the change of discipline from Communion on the tongue, kneeling, to Communion on the hand, standing, has been the cause of persons falling away from the true Faith, and the cause of the heresy … Continue reading

Gallery | Leave a comment

If Pope Francis and Vatican II taught heresy…

… certain conclusions are implied. First of all, no valid Pope can teach heresy, so Pope Francis would have to be an antipope. And the same is true for Ecumenical Councils. No valid Council can teach heresy. So if Vatican … Continue reading

Gallery | 1 Comment

The Errors of Bishop Schneider on Jews and Muslims

Read my previous post on this subject. Recently Bishop Schneider reasserted this error, in an interview with Taylor Marshall. He claims that Jews and Muslims cannot have supernatural faith.

Gallery | Leave a comment