Summary of My Theology: on Hell

1. Immediately after death, each and every human person is judged by God. (Pope Benedict XII, On the Beatific Vision of God) 2. All those persons who die unrepentant from actual mortal sin are sent to Hell by God. (Pope … Continue reading

More Galleries

The Distinction between Lying and Mental Reservation

Lying is the direct and deliberate deprivation of truth from an assertion. It is the intentional choice of an act inherently directed at asserting what is false. Lying is intrinsically evil and therefore always immoral. Mental reservation, properly defined and … Continue reading

More Galleries

Which Papal Encyclical has been most thoroughly rejected by Catholics?

The faithful sons and daughters of the Church should accept the teaching of Sacred Tradition and Sacred Scripture and the Magisterium. We should not reject any encyclical in which the Magisterium teaches from Tradition and Scripture, or from natural law. … Continue reading

More Galleries

Lying and Ethics by Example

In discussions on lying, many Catholics approach the question by proposing various examples of acts that seem to be both lies and moral. They then resolve this conflict by either claiming that lying is not always immoral, or by claiming … Continue reading

More Galleries | 3 Comments

Errors on Lying at the New Theological Movement blog

In this post, It is a sin to lie, even to Planned Parenthood, a Catholic priest, posting under the pseudonym ‘Reginaldus’, discusses Catholic doctrine on lying. The main point of the post is that lying is always immoral. This point … Continue reading

More Galleries | 2 Comments

Unintended Bad Consequences

One common error in Catholic ethics is the claim that an act cannot be made immoral by a bad consequence, if that consequence is unintended. On the basis of this claim, unintended bad consequences, no matter how severe, are incorrectly … Continue reading

More Galleries

Ethics by Example

There is a certain erroneous approach to ethics that might be called ‘ethics by example’. In this approach, an intrinsically evil act is said to be sometimes moral, if anyone can cite an example of that type of act that … Continue reading

More Galleries

Ethics without Sacrifice

The latest trend in Catholic ethical thinking is what might be called ‘ethics without sacrifice’. In this approach to morality, any moral analysis is said to be incorrect if it implies that one must suffer in order to avoid sin. … Continue reading

More Galleries

Is Lying Always Wrong? — part 3: Saint Augustine

It is often incorrectly stated that St. Augustine defined lying as follows: ” ‘A lie consists in speaking a falsehood with the intention of deceiving.’ ” This text is a quote in the Catechism of the Catholic Church, n. 2482; … Continue reading

More Galleries

143 German Catholic theologians commit public formal heresy

The German daily sueddeutsche.de has published the Memorandum of 143 Catholic university professors and theologians, mostly from Germany, with some from Austria and Switzerland. [Google translation] The document begins with a brief discussion of the sexual abuse crisis in the … Continue reading

More Galleries

Intramural apologetics: teachers of heresy abound

Catholic laypersons are called by Christ and His Church, in the apostolate of the laity, to evangelize the world, to bring Christ and His teaching to those who do not know the Truth. But we are hobbled in our efforts … Continue reading

More Galleries

Is the Magisterium able to answer all moral questions?

I have been surprised and dismayed lately, in the wake of the distorted news coverage of the Pope’s comment on condoms, to read several different prominent Catholics making the claim that the Magisterium is unwilling or unable to teach and … Continue reading

More Galleries